St Regis vs Montage Deer Valley | In-Depth Comparison Guide

Park city Utah

Our team developed this St Regis vs Montage Deer Valley comparison guide to help you decide which hotel is the best option to spend some quality time with your family. In fact, both hotels are great options to discover Deer Valley, where you can take a moment to relax, and start new adventures immersed into nature every day, but there are considerable differences between these two hotels to keep in mind if you want to experience the best during your stay. 

Deer Valley offers great experiences both in the summer time and in the winter time.

In the summer, this area offers excellent hiking paths and biking trails. You can capture breathtaking, scenic views of the surrounding mountains from the chairlifts. It is also possible to plan an adventurous horseback riding and guided historical hikes.

Deer Valley also offers a fun summer concert series that is the perfect occasion for everyone to let loose and mingle together.

In the winter time, there is no better place to ski than in Deer Valley. Its highly-rated slopes are perfect for skiers and snowboarders. Of course, for those who are not a pro yet, there are top notch instructors who can provide ski lessons. It is also possible to rent the equipment right on the site. Best of all, whichever hotel you choose, you will not even need to use a car since there are shuttles from the hotels that will make your life so much easier.

But, which hotel gives you the best chances to experience everything you are looking for during your vacation? Let’s have a look at this breakdown between St Regis vs Montage Deer Valley.

Please note that this post may contain affiliate links, which means that we receive a small commission if you make a booking through our links, but at no extra cost to you. This helps keep our site running. Thank you in advance for your support!

St Regis vs Montage Deer Valley - Overview & Location

The St. Regis Deer Valley and the Montage Deer Valley hotels are both nestled in the mountains of Park City, UT and are quite close to each other. Both the St. Regis and the Montage are located within a few minutes from Park City and Park City Mountain Resort, which can be reached from both hotels in about a 10 to 15 minutes drive. To provide their guests with the best comfort, both hotels provide a ski-in/ski-out service, which means that you don’t need to drive or even take a shuttle to access the nearest ski resort.

Both hotels also offer a complimentary shuttle service to drive their guests to Main Street, where you can find a countless number of restaurants and shops.

Meanwhile, Salt Lake City International Airport is located approximately 50 minutes by car from both hotels.

The St. Regis Hotel can arrange, upon request, a private shuttle to come and pick you up from the airport. The hotel also offers complimentary local transportation anywhere within 5 miles from the hotel.

Both hotels offer outstanding services for their guests, including a wellness spa and great dining experiences. The St. Regis Deer Valley has also a spacious fitness center for guests who want to train with heavy weights or practice some cardio.

Additionally, both the St. Regis and the Montage Deer Valley hotels offer an outstanding venue for couples that want to celebrate their weddings in an intimate, yet elegant, atmosphere.

St Regis vs Montage Deer Valley - Room Options

The St. Regis has a wide variety of rooms and suites that can accommodate couples, families, and groups of friends that are traveling together. In both cases, the rooms and the suites offer a spacious place to relax with stunning views of the surrounding mountains.

Here, it is possible to book a luxury suite that welcomes guests with a cozy, yet sophisticated alpine design in a one bedroom style layout. There are also the Unique Residences that come with two bedrooms that are perfect for families or groups of friends.

The extensive range of room choices also include Superior rooms, which are roughly 410 to 435 square feet, and Deluxe rooms, which are slightly bigger at 440 to 485 square feet. It is possible to choose which view to wake up to and if you want a fireplace for those cozy winter nights.

The Montage Deer Valley also offers a variety of rooms and suites for their guests. All of them have large windows from where it is possible to have a view of the valley or the mountains. Some rooms have a private balcony or patio as well.

The Montage offers three main categories of room options:

  • Rooms
  • Suites
  • Residences

Rooms are designed in the traditional hotel style layout, in a studio setup with either one king bed or two queen beds.

The Suites offer more space and provide a separate living and dining area as well as a choice between a junior suite, one bedroom or two bedrooms. They are appointed with high-quality furniture and all offer a fireplace. Some even come with a fully equipped kitchen.

The Residences are the most lavish room choice and range from one to four bedrooms in an exclusive one or two story layout.

Overall, there are great options for rooms or suites available at both the St. Regis and Montage Deer Valley. Our choice for large groups of up to 10 people who want to stay together is the Montage since it offers three and four bedroom residences where everyone can stay.

Either way, you will not be disappointed with either hotel’s service and quality.

St Regis vs Montage Deer Valley - Amenities & Restaurants

The St. Regis Hotel provides a wellness experience like no other. At the hotel, it is possible to enjoy a quiet and relaxing time at the spa, where you can also take advantage and relax with a massage.

The St. Regis Athletic Club is the place to stay fit and pump your muscles. This large fitness center is open 24 hours a day and offers access to the best gym equipment as well as weights.

There is also the outdoor heated pool, which is the perfect place to spend some time with family and friends. Since it is heated, you can take a dip all season long, after a summer hike or a day on the slopes. The views of the mountains from the outdoor pool are just as stunning as from the peaks.

At the Montage Deer Valley, you can enjoy the luxurious, 35,000 square foot wellness center that provides an incredible experience, with its jacuzzi pools, steam rooms, and redwood saunas. It is possible to reserve special treatments not only for your body, but for your mind and spirit, too.

Additionally, you can book private fitness classes at the Montage, from yoga training, to pilates, spin, and stretching.

Regarding restaurants, the St. Regis Hotel offers some of the most exquisite cuisine in all of their restaurants. The St. Regis Deer Valley features a traditional dining experience at their RIME Seafood and Steak restaurant, which is set in a rustic, yet elegant decor.

The St. Regis Bar is the perfect location for a cocktail or a quick snack before dinner, while instead the Brasserie 7452 is a French restaurant that serves tasty food for the whole family.

Additionally, the Mountain Terrace is the outdoor area to sip a coffee while overlooking the Deer Valley. It also offers a dining service. 

At the Montage Deer Valley, there is a vast choice of restaurants to try. There is the Apex restaurant, which is the Montage’s elegant signature restaurant that is open for every meal. In the evening, it transforms into Apex Steak and serves up some of the best steaks in the area.

For a more relaxed dinner, there is the Burgers & Bourbon restaurant that offers  simple, yet high quality gourmet fare like burgers with fries.

The Montage also offers a restaurant that serves brick-oven pizzas (Daly’s Pub & Rec) and sushi (Yama Sushi). If you are craving a quick bite or a good coffee, Buzz Coffee & Tea is the place to go. There is a large menu that offers a variety of coffee, teas, freshly baked pastries, and sandwiches.

St Regis vs Montage Deer Valley - What Others Are Saying

We have researched what other guests have said after staying at the St. Regis Deer Valley and at the Montage Deer Valley from different online platforms like TripAdvisor, Facebook, and In this section, we highlight the comments that we believe can be useful for you to make a decision between these two hotels.

St. Regis Deer Valley:

  • Both hotels provide a great service to their guests, but the St. Regis is just a touch more friendly – the best detail was the welcome food tray during check-in that contained warm chocolate chip cookies, candies, and fruit
  • Kids and adults are delighted with daily s’mores and hot chocolate
  • The amazing staff at the St. Regis impressively remembers names of the hotel’s guests during the whole stay
  • Guests have noted that The St. Regis Deer Valley has a slightly better customer service
  • The room service at The St. Regis only took about 30 to 35 minutes to be sent up
  • It is possible to reach different areas within The St. Regis Resort with a cool funicular system (the funicular runs between the Snow Park Residences and the St. Regis Upper Resort building)
  • The St. Regis has a very nice outdoor fire-pit
  • Guests appreciate the atmosphere of the apres-ski at St. Regis, either in their bar or on the deck by the fire pit

Montage Deer Valley:

  • Guests have noted that the facilities at the Montage Deer Valley are newer
  • After staying at both hotels, guests comment that the rooms at the Montage Deer Valley were a bit bigger, “probably 10-20% larger”
  • It is ideal for large groups with the 3 and 4 bedroom options
  • The room service the Montage Deer Valley took about 40 minutes to be completed
  • The rooms are excellently appointed with lots of couches and many have fireplaces
  • The Montage hotel has a better location for reaching the slopes

St Regis vs Montage Deer Valley - Summary

It is clear from the guests’ reviews and from our in-depth research that we can conclude that both the St. Regis and the Montage Deer Valley hotels will provide you with great service, high quality restaurants, and good connections to the slopes. Both hotels have amazing views of the mountains and a luxurious spa and wellness area to allow you to relax during your stay.

Your choice will need to depend on your preferences and style, but be sure that there really is no wrong option.